Noah's living

Baking, hiking, and the occasional book

Learning to bake sourdough

2 June 2025

I started a sourdough starter in January and spent the next four months producing things that were, in varying ways, inedible. Too dense, too flat, too sour, too pale. My partner ate polite slices and said nothing. I researched endlessly and adjusted variables one at a time and still couldn't get the thing to work reliably. At some point I accepted that I was just in the awkward middle phase that every new skill has, and I kept going.

The breakthrough, when it came, was small and a little anticlimactic. I'd been stretching and folding the dough every thirty minutes during bulk fermentation — exactly as the guide said — but I'd been doing it in a cold kitchen. I moved the bowl to a warmer spot on top of the fridge, and suddenly the dough started behaving the way the pictures in books showed it should. It got airy and alive and slightly domed at the edges. I shaped it badly, as I always do, but it didn't matter.

The loaf I pulled from the oven that evening had a proper crust — one that crackled when I tapped it and sounded hollow, which I'd read about but never achieved. The crumb wasn't perfect; it had a few tunnels and one large air pocket near the bottom. But it tasted like bread is supposed to taste, with a faint sourness and a chew and a crust that stayed crisp into the next morning.

What I've come to love about sourdough isn't the bread itself, though the bread is good. It's the way it structures a day without demanding too much of it. The starter needs feeding; the dough needs turning; the timing loosely dictates when you have to be home. It's a kind of low-stakes obligation that I find oddly comforting. The kitchen smells of something happening, and that turns out to matter more than I expected.

I still produce the occasional flat disaster. The starter sulks in cold weather and goes overenthusiastic in summer. But I understand it better now, and I know that understanding will keep accumulating, slowly, the way it does with anything worth learning.